ACDT2026-06-01_081

AllCoreDevs - Testing #081

2026-06-01 5 decisions 582 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

EIP-8045 included in glamsterdam-devnet-5; all CL teams in agreement
glamsterdam-devnet-4 abandoned; not recovered
glamsterdam-devnet-5 is CL-only (EIP-8045 + stability fixes); all EL changes target glamsterdam-devnet-6
Priority order for EL work: benchmarking/optimizations > self-destruct burn (EIP-8246) > EIP-7997
Gas repricing breakout calls ended; all discussion moves to ACDT
glamsterdam-devnet-5 launch - as early as tomorrow (June 2), pending alpha.9 spec release
bal-devnet-8 / glamsterdam-devnet-6 decision deferred to ACDT next week

Detailed notes

Spec Changes

  • •EIP-7928 spec change merged: SlotChanges must contain at least one StorageChange (no empty sets)00:21:15
  • •EIP-7928 state-access decoupling PR open: charge 100 gas pre-depth/balance checks, then remaining 2500 after; Reth proposed, most clients need changes00:23:52
  • •EIP-8037 auth refund expansion PR open (5-rule scheme): refund state gas for invalid or net-zero authorization list entries00:31:14
  • •EIP-2780 simplification pending: remove self-transfer and precompile carve-outs; awaiting benchmark results before merge00:38:29

Testing Progress

  • •bal-devnet-7 stable with 100% EVM fuzzing participation; clients iterating on benchmarking00:07:33
  • •EIP-7975 (eth/70) and EIP-8159 (eth/71) confirmed implemented across all EL clients00:08:43
  • •Final test release tests-bal@v7.3.0 will be cut once EIP-8037 lands in forks/amsterdam00:11:14

Fork Status And Schedule

  • •glamsterdam-devnet-4 abandoned following ePBS split at ~slot 22800; root cause: should_build_on_full / PTC timing bug00:12:51
  • •EIP-8045 (exclude slashed validators from proposing) included in glamsterdam-devnet-5; all CL teams confirmed ready or near-ready00:19:54
  • •Consensus: glamsterdam-devnet-5 CL-only; all EL changes (EIP-8246, EIP-2780, EIP-8038, EIP-7954, EIP-7997) deferred to glamsterdam-devnet-601:02:06
  • •Benchmarking optimizations on bal-devnet-7 are the primary EL blocker; must complete before final gas cost numbers can land00:55:17

Action items

  • •EL teams review EIP-7928 state-access decoupling PR before ACDE ThursdayAll EL teams
  • •danceratopz to open ETH R&D thread outlining glamsterdam-devnet-5 scope for async consensusdanceratopz

Agenda

From the call issue #2085Show

Glamsterdam

Heads up: As repricing specs have stabilized, the fortnightly Wednesday Gas Repricing Breakout Calls held by @misilva73 have stopped; any required discussion will happen in ACDT.

Devnet Status and Benchmarking
  • bal-devnet-7, hive dashboard, dora:

    • Stable, 100% EVM fuzzing participation (reported in Repricings #8) @qu0b.
    • Clients:
      • eth/70 (EIP-7975) and eth/71 (EIP-8159) are mandatory on bal-devnet-7 - is this work complete? @qu0b.
    • Final test release tests-bal@v7.3.0 once 8037 lands in forks/amsterdam, tracker: ethereum/execution-specs#2912 @spencer-tb.
  • Benchmarking / repricing status (@misilva73 + client teams):

    • State of client BAL optimizations in bal-devnet-7 branches? Per-client round.
      • ethrex reports ~3x exec speed-up vs devnet-3?
      • Nethermind OOM affecting benchmarking results?
      • Besu (shipped AOT and an OOM fix).
      • Geth BAL opt branch this week?
    • How much of a priority is it to replace the perf-devnet-3 snapshots with ethereum/state-actor? (execution-specs#2916). This can be deferred to tomorrow's Gas Lighting call.
  • glamsterdam-devnet-4 not so healthy as of ~May 25::

    • Chain split ~slot 22800; prysm-nethermind-1 forked on EMPTY after missing the 22800 payload.
    • PR (consensus-specs#5307).
    • Recover the chain or abandon for devnet-5?
Spec Changes
  • EIP-7928 heads up: ethereum/EIPs#11750, (merged) by @raxhvl, flagged by @bharnett:

    • Each SlotChanges MUST contain >=1 StorageChange (no empty change sets); EELS test added.
  • EIP-7928, @nerolation wants to discuss decoupling state-access validation from EIP-2929: stack-depth and balance checks move into the pre-state phase, and cold-access warming plus BAL insertion are now paired with each post-state access-cost charge.

  • EIP-8037 heads up ethereum/EIPs#11706 (merged) @misilva73.

    • Calldata floor accounting alignment & call-frame refill clarification
  • EIP-8037, ethereum/EIPs#11715, 8037 (open) by @rjl493456442:

    • Expand EIP-7702 authorization gas refunds (5-rule per-authorization scheme).
    • Client-team opinions before approving: do we want this added refund complexity / any attack vectors?
  • EIP-2780, ethereum/EIPs#11735, 2780 in draft by @rakita:

    • Remove the self-transfer and precompile intrinsic-gas carve-outs; always charge tx.to at the cold rate.
    • Open: keep charging TRANSFER_LOG_COST for self-transfers when EIP-7708 emits no log? (@benaadams objects; @rakita agrees PR will change.)
    • Architectural gate (@gurukamath): one gas cost, or split Code vs No-Code accounts? Blocks the impl + numbers.
  • EIP-8246 Remove SELFDESTRUCT Burn: Review, required by EIP-7708 @chfast - in the devnet-5 set?

Glamsterdam spec next TODOs
  1. Finalize gas repricings numbers (ongoing on bal-devnet-7).
  2. CL stability; resolve consensus-specs#5307.
  3. Include new EL EIPS: i. EIP-8246 (remove self-destruct burn). ii. EIP-2780 (intrinsic gas) and EIP-8038 (state-access gas cost update), requires 1., but not 4.
  4. Updated EL EIP: EIP-7954 (increase max contract size w/larger numbers).
  5. EL EIP spec changes as above.
  6. Any other CL changes?

i. EIP-8045: Exclude slashed validators from proposing. ii. EIP-7688: Forward compatible consensus data structures @etan-status? iii. ...

Options and scoping of glamsterdam-devnet-5 OR next devnets
  1. Clean glamsterdam-devnet-4 spec relaunch. (CL ask from ACDC #179: stability first, no scope increase for 2 weeks).
  2. glamsterdam-devnet-4 with bal-devnet-7 (with or without some SFId EL EIP spec changes, details below).
  3. As 2. but with bal-devnet-7 with 2780/8038 placeholder numbers.
  4. Launch two devnets simultaneously and merge into later devnet: i. glamsterdam-devnet-5 for CL stability. ii. bal-devnet-8 for close-to-final EL spec. iii. -> merge into glamsterdam-devnet-6.
  • Timing of devnet launch(es)?
Other Topics

Please comment on this issue with other topics!

Last call:

Key decisions

  • EIP-8045 included in glamsterdam-devnet-5; all CL teams in agreement

    glamsterdam-devnet-5
  • glamsterdam-devnet-4 abandoned; not recovered

    DFI
  • glamsterdam-devnet-5 is CL-only (EIP-8045 + stability fixes); all EL changes target glamsterdam-devnet-6

    glamsterdam-devnet-5CL-only, EL changes in glamsterdam-devnet-6
  • Priority order for EL work: benchmarking/optimizations > self-destruct burn (EIP-8246) > EIP-7997

    Priority order for EL work
  • Gas repricing breakout calls ended; all discussion moves to ACDT

    Gas repricing breakout calls ended

EIPs discussed

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.