P2P2026-11-18_011

P2P Networking #011

2026-11-18 3 decisions 760 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

Felix to share unified networking specs repo in Discord rather than bringing to ACD first; CL team buy-in required before any canonical transition
P2P call time moved 5h 30m earlier; Kamil to update protocol calendar invite

Detailed notes

Client Updates

  • •Lodestar (jxs): researching EIP-8411 integration, exploring Waggle app/network interface boundary00:06:29
  • •Prysm: beginning EIP-8411 prototype; reviewing Daniel's PR for 1-1 Waggle integration00:07:37
  • •Nethermind: P2P improvements in .NET; interested in PQ-related protocols; will review EIP-8411 this week00:08:38
  • •Geth (Felix): mempool improvements; working on post-quantum ENR and Discovery v5 transition plan; to post in Discord00:09:43
  • •Lodestar (cayman): building new Ethereum-tailored networking stack in Zig; js-libp2p moving to maintenance mode00:11:05
  • •Silver (vlad): libp2p-compatible but not libp2p; producing production-ready Rust zkast library00:12:00
  • •Ethlambda: beacon client launched, presented in Cambridge; experimenting with PQ signature sizes vs BLS00:12:54

Organizational

  • •Call time moving ~5h 30m earlier to accommodate Europe/Southeast Asia/Australia attendees; invite to be updated00:14:08

Webtx Protocol

  • •Geth (Bosul): WebTX — new sub-protocol allowing browsers to submit transactions directly to EL P2P network via WebTransport/QUIC, bypassing RPC00:53:10
  • •ENR extended with certificate hash field (QH); two-week rotation with advance announcement; identity proof via signed challenge on session open00:55:14
  • •Browser connections limited: 10s lifetime, disconnect after first message, IP-based rate limiting on invalid transactions00:58:20
  • •Protocol is write-only (transaction submit + result response); peer exchange planned; onion routing considered long-term01:01:32
  • •WebTX merged in Geth; browser→node connections testable on mainnet today; spec PR: ethereum/devp2p#27601:11:12

Eip 8411 Waggle

  • •EIP-8411 is CFI for Hegota; scope may be reconsidered pending upcoming ACDC discussions01:34:41
  • •Daniel's PR (EIPs#12671) updates EIP-8411 to use Waggle; Lighthouse implementation PR#10604 available for CL teams to assess complexity01:34:58
  • •Csaba: preparing PR to clarify EIP-8411 chunking descriptor and Reed-Solomon scheme01:35:28

Networking Specs

  • •Felix demoed unified P2P networking spec repo merging devp2p (EL) and consensus-specs (CL) networking into one place00:17:36
  • •Repo introduces legacy/current/experimental versioning; full reified specs per version; EIP-named draft files for in-progress proposals00:18:32
  • •CL networking spec compiled to single up-to-date document (v6 at Gloas); fork-based versioning retained; gossip validation functions stay in consensus-specs00:23:55
  • •Planned additions: Waggle and zkast under new 'broadcast' directory; QUIC transport spec; libp2p adapter spec00:25:55
  • •jxs: Lodestar drove QUIC adoption but has no plans to deprecate TCP; cayman: QUIC-only vision appealing long-term; Silver is QUIC-only00:43:51

Xmss Signature Broadcast Simulations

  • •Kamil ran gossip-sub simulations (~3,700 nodes, 32K validators) for XMSS/large-signature attestation propagation01:13:05
  • •Reducing gossip-sub mesh degree from 8→4 cuts average duplicates from 4→2.5 with no latency regression01:20:22
  • •Staggered push approach (hash peer IDs + message to assign pusher/waiter role) reduces duplicates to ~1.6; propagation latency unchanged or improved01:21:03
  • •ProbeLab (Mikel): simulations reflect happy path only; adversarial/churn scenarios (eclipse, delayed forwarding) should be included in roadmap01:28:21
  • •cayman: simulations should include EIP-7870 bandwidth-bound nodes; bad numbers justify updating bandwidth assumptions01:29:54

Action items

  • •Review unified networking specs repo; provide feedback before Felix presents more broadlyCL client teams (especially active consensus-specs contributors)
  • •Review Lighthouse EIP-8411 Waggle implementation (PR#10604) to assess integration complexityCL client teams

Agenda

From the call issue #2302Show

– Clients updates – Networking specs (Felix) – XMSS signatures broadcast simulations (Kamil) – 8411, waggle discussions

Key decisions

  • Felix to share unified networking specs repo in Discord rather than bringing to ACD first; CL team buy-in required before any canonical transition

    The transition to a unified networking specification repository (merging EL and CL networking) requires consensus from CL teams before being presented to the All Core Devs call.
  • P2P call time moved 5h 30m earlier; Kamil to update protocol calendar invite

    The meeting time was adjusted to better accommodate attendees in Europe, Southeast Asia, and Australia.
  • EIP-8411 is CFI for Hegota; scope may be reconsidered pending upcoming ACDC discussions

    CFIEIP-8411 (Waggle) has been designated as Considered for Inclusion for the Hegota upgrade, though its scope remains subject to further discussion.

EIPs discussed

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.