PQTS2026-10-28_017

PQ Transaction Signatures #017

2026-10-28 1 decision 465 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

Adopt sphincs.art parameter set (broadly equivalent to Project 11 proposal) for next testnet upgrade; lifetime left open pending offline discussion — starting conservatively high (2^30–2^32) until field data clarifies rotation needs
Updated lean SPHINCS parameters deployed to testnet — within two weeks

Detailed notes

Testnet Update

  • •Testnet v03 launched on Daisugi (with Nethermind): single tx with STARK proof of 20 SPHINCS signatures under EIP-828800:17:58
  • •Post-DevCon testnet planned with EthPandaOps spam tooling for better benchmarks00:18:28

Sphincs Parameter Proposals

  • •sphincs.art tool presented: explores SPHINCS parameter trade-offs (lifetime, shape, hash, FTS type) for lean SPHINCS00:19:05
  • •Default lifetime on sphincs.art is 2^30 (~1B signatures); reducing to 2^24 cuts size but raises key-rotation frequency00:20:19
  • •Pruning improves keygen speed but leaks privacy after ~75 signatures; partial fix requires semi-trusted state, yields ~2,000 private sigs on Ledger00:23:44
  • •Forest-of-WOTS (Vitale FTS from Sea Golf/Blockstream) gives >30% signing speedup but is novel, less MPC-friendly, and needs standard-model security proof00:25:43
  • •Project 11 proposes two parameter sets: both use WOTS/WOTS+C, CAIC hash, lifetime 2^24; optimized for hardware wallets and MPC (SPHINCS G variant)00:40:52

Lifetime And Key Rotation Debate

  • •Bitcoin SPHINCS (Shrinks) currently at 2^40; Mikhail Kridinov open to lower values; Justin Drake advocates cross-chain alignment00:49:10
  • •Circle hot wallets sign 30K–70K tx/day (~2^16–2^17); at 2^24 lifetime that is ~1.5 years before rotation00:57:25
  • •Nico: surveyed 5 major exchanges — all said key rotation is trivially automatable; anything above 2^22–2^23 is sufficient01:02:09
  • •Justin Drake argues for higher lifetime (2^30): easier UX communication, alignment with Bitcoin/Zcash, and room to reduce later01:12:31
  • •Chat note: Bitcoin 2^40 accounts for off-chain protocols (e.g., high-volume Lightning nodes), not just on-chain use01:15:38

Mpc And Hardware Wallet Constraints

  • •WOTS forest is structurally worse for MPC (nearly 100% secret hashes vs ~50% for FORS); not just a compute-power problem00:55:13
  • •Project 11: 2^24→2^32 lifetime difference is make-or-break for SPHINCS G on Ledger; MPC is unaffected up to ~2^2801:06:40
  • •Justin Drake: proof-of-grinding via SNARK (host offloads grinding to laptop, proves correctness) expected to improve ~10x in ~12 months01:15:50

Action items

  • •Circle (Daniel) to report internally on key-rotation feasibility and return with findings next callDaniel Cason / Circle
  • •Emil to add 2^24 lifetime toggle to sphincs.art so parameter sets can be compared directlyTom Wambsgans (Emil)

Agenda

From the call issue #2283Show

Key decisions

  • Adopt sphincs.art parameter set (broadly equivalent to Project 11 proposal) for next testnet upgrade; lifetime left open pending offline discussion — starting conservatively high (2^30–2^32) until field data clarifies rotation needs

    The group decided to use the sphincs.art parameters for the next testnet, choosing a higher initial lifetime for signatures to align with Bitcoin/Zcash and simplify UX until more data on key rotation is available.

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.