Agenda
1. Versioning Proposal Review
Proposal Document: Execution APIs v1.0.0 - Versioning Proposal, ethereum-magicians
Review the v1.0.0 versioning proposal and gather team input on:
- Overall scope agreement (71 methods, through Cancun fork)
- PRs to merge before tagging (#753, #742)
- Deferred items list approval
2. Open Questions Requiring Team Decision
| Question | Options | Related Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Error code standardization | A) Before v1 (delays release) B) Defer to v2 | #658, #650 |
| Test coverage gap (11 methods) | A) Block v1 until complete B) Release with gaps | #737 |
| eth_simulateV1 maxUseGas | A) Include in v1 B) Defer to v1.1 | #746 |
| EIP-1898 compliance | A) Full compliance before v1 B) Document current state | #713 |
3. Open Issues
| Issue | Title | Priority |
|---|---|---|
| #690 | API versioning via GitHub releases/tags | Critical |
| #658 | Standardize JSON-RPC Error codes | Critical |
| #713 | Fully apply EIP-1898 in specs | High |
| #737 | Missing Test Coverage for 11 methods | Medium |
| #663 | GenericTransaction Should Contain data | Medium |
4. Open PRs
| PR | Title | Author | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| #753 | Fix: engine nits | - | Ready for merge |
| #747 | Add testing_buildBlockV1 RPC Method | Pandas | Needs Marius review |
| #746 | Add maxUseGas field to eth_simulateV1 | - | Discussion needed |
| #742 | test(debug_getRawReceipts): post-Byzantium block | - | Ready for merge |
| #735 | EIP-8025 | - | Deferred |
| #726 | Add EIP-7928 Block-level Access Lists | - | Deferred |
5. Outdated / Stalled PRs
Review and decide: close or revive?
Identified in previous meeting - several PRs from 2023 may be abandoned