RPC2026-05-18_026

RPC Standards #026

2026-05-18 4 decisions 625 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

Merge PR removing eth_getUncle* methods from spec; data unavailable on any current client
Defer PR #797 (eth_subscribe) until OpenRPC spec version is upgraded to 1.4
eth_fillTransaction to be updated: remove unsigned encoded payload from response; retain default-filling behavior only
Documentation versioning: retain 'Next' label for main branch in versioned docs site
End of week - documentation versioning PR to be opened by zcstarr
Next call - discuss Hive eth_simulateV1 test failures and error code alignment in detail

Detailed notes

Hive Test Failures

  • •Nethermind reported eth_simulateV1 Hive failures: multiple test cases failing on same generic error code; need distinct error codes per scenario or reduce test cases01:09:00
  • •Root cause: clients validate EVM operations in different orders, causing different error codes; proposal to allow multiple acceptable error codes per test fixture01:11:17

Open Rpc Versioning

  • •OpenRPC 1.4 resolves Go binding and versioning issues; upgrade unblocks PR #797 (eth_subscribe specification)00:16:38
  • •Documentation versioning demo shown: version dropdown, 'Next' for main branch, release notes workflow, and method tagging all functional; PR coming end of week01:01:21

Specification Updates

  • •Agreed to merge PR #791 (JSON-RPC invalid params error code clarification) and rename it appropriately00:06:43
  • •Agreed to merge PR removing uncle methods from spec; no clients store uncle data anymore, untestable00:11:00
  • •PR #762 (debug_traceTransaction standardization) ready to merge pending Felix review; implemented and approved across Geth, Besu, Erigon, Nethermind00:23:14
  • •PR #790 (eth_getConfig) agreed to merge; replacement for prior PR with corrected auto-generated files00:33:59

Missing Methods Review

  • •HackMD overview of methods missing from spec identified; focus should be methods implemented in 3–4 clients00:34:24
  • •eth_fillTransaction security concern raised by Nethermind: returning unsigned binary payload is risky; proposal to remove encoded output from method scope00:38:26
  • •debug_executionWitness not in spec despite all-client implementation; straightforward candidate for a new PR00:45:18

Action items

  • •Open PR to upgrade execution-apis OpenRPC spec version to 1.4; unblocks PR #797Mercy Boma Naps-Nkari
  • •Open PR to add debug_executionWitness to execution-apis specMercy Boma Naps-Nkari
  • •Bring missing-methods HackMD list to ACDE for broader input on what to standardize or dropMercy Boma Naps-Nkari

Agenda

From the call issue #2056Show

Key decisions

  • Merge PR removing eth_getUncle* methods from spec; data unavailable on any current client

  • Defer PR #797 (eth_subscribe) until OpenRPC spec version is upgraded to 1.4

    PR #797 is dependent on OpenRPC spec version upgrade
  • eth_fillTransaction to be updated: remove unsigned encoded payload from response; retain default-filling behavior only

  • Documentation versioning: retain 'Next' label for main branch in versioned docs site

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.