RPC2026-06-29_029

RPC Standards #029

2026-06-29 3 decisions 475 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

Glamsterdam/Amsterdam spec changes without tests will use a tracking issue or long-running branch; tests backfilled once fork spec is final
Byte-type regex PR (#81415) approved to merge — restricting to lowercase aligns with all other byte types in spec
Error code rework still in progress; no merge of current PR until Sina's updated positive-number proposal is ready; broader ACD discussion planned

Detailed notes

Pr Reviews

  • •execution-apis PR #814 (eth_getRawTransaction endpoints): all clients merged except ethrex (PR approved, not merged); CI spell-check failure is upstream noise — rerun to green, ready to merge00:23:13
  • •PR adding slot number to block header schema (Glamsterdam): marked for Amsterdam label; needs tests deferred until fork spec is final00:24:43
  • •PR adding 3 missing eth_getRaw* endpoints (by hash/block): all EL clients already implement these; blocked on Go Ethereum PR #35227 merge + test regeneration00:33:28
  • •Regex fix for single-byte type (PR #81415): change to allow single zero in decimal numbers is correct; uppercase hex oddity in byte type resolved — approved to merge00:37:22

Error Codes

  • •New error code direction: define all new codes as strictly positive integers; positive = reliable/new, negative = legacy/fuzzy; Go Ethereum considering a legacy-mode mapper for transition period00:55:58
  • •Sina's updated proposal pending; grouping debate: user-friendly categories (gas errors, nonce errors) vs. implementation-layer categories (execution, simulation, validation); to be brought to ACD for broader input01:00:16

Debug Execution Witness

  • •debug_executionWitness has no cross-client spec agreement: Geth uses JSON header with empty key; Reth/Nethermind/Erigon use RLP bytes with populated key; Geth and Reth also expose a separate by-hash method — needs spec decision01:06:07

Action items

  • •Merge Go Ethereum PR #35227, cut new release, regenerate execution-apis I/O tests for eth_getRaw* PRGeth (Felix)
  • •Open a tracked issue for debug_executionWitness wire format disagreement; tag relevant stakeholders (Kev)Boma

Agenda

From the call issue #2141Show

Key decisions

  • Glamsterdam/Amsterdam spec changes without tests will use a tracking issue or long-running branch; tests backfilled once fork spec is final

    spec changes without tests will use a tracking issue or long-running branch
  • Byte-type regex PR (#81415) approved to merge — restricting to lowercase aligns with all other byte types in spec

    Byte-type regex PR approved to merge
  • Error code rework still in progress; no merge of current PR until Sina's updated positive-number proposal is ready; broader ACD discussion planned

    Error code rework still in progress

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.