ACDE2026-11-19_249

AllCoreDevs - Execution #249

2026-11-19 4 decisions 636 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

Glamsterdam will proceed with current spec (no changes); Hoodi fork targeting week of Dec 14 — formal go/no-go at next ACDC
Top Hegota scope option (drop frames, enshrine PQ directly) has zero support — effectively DFI'd; remaining options 2–4 open for two-week client team review
No cross-layer Hegota DevNet until FOCIL decision is made on ACDC; EL DevNets remain separate
EL DevNet scope paused at current level by default; ACDT Monday may greenlight cleanup EIPs only
Hoodi fork — week of December 14, 2026 (Dec 16–17 likely); confirmed/cancelled at ACDC Nov 26verify date
Frames spec-complete (all major changes merged) — before holiday break, mid-December 2026verify date

Detailed notes

Hegota Scope

  • •Scope options debated (1–5); rough landing zone between option 3 (core frames bundle only) and 4 (frames + select EIPs); option 1 (enshrine PQ, drop frames) has zero support00:51:33
  • •Besu/ethrex lean toward freezing at Hegota devnet 2 scope + adding leanSPHINCS/signature aggregation; Nethermind prefers not reducing unless it accelerates shipping00:57:46
  • •EIP-8151 (EC Recover deprecation) flagged as high-risk: preliminary scan shows many contracts depend on it; may not make Hegota00:58:52
  • •Greg Colvin: repeated EIP removals/delays cause planning hardship for champions; argues for sliding fork dates rather than dropping EIPs01:05:54

Hegota Devnets

  • •Decision: no cross-layer DevNet until ACDC decides on FOCIL; EL-only DevNets remain separate01:27:13
  • •Default: pause at current EL DevNet scope; possible exception for cleanup EIPs if strong ACDT consensus Monday01:36:43

Fork Status And Schedule

  • •EF/ChainSecurity/DDOB contacted 50+ affected companies; all highs fix by mid-Dec, mediums by Jan 1000:10:49
  • •Glamsterdam mainnet target: mid-Jan earliest (no spec changes); late-Jan/early-Feb more realistic00:14:44
  • •Hoodi fork week of Dec 14 (Dec 16–17) penciled in; go/no-go decision deferred to next ACDC00:44:49

Frames Transaction Updates

  • •Frames breakout: two open spec changes — (1) forward-compat with EIP-8288 signature list, (2) tree-root hashing scheme; target spec-complete before holiday break01:21:32
  • •ethrex (Iván) proposing minimal leanSPHINCS-on-frames EIP (ethereum/EIPs#12672); 8288-compatible, no prover/aggregation yet; targeting PFI next ACDE01:23:37

Pq Cryptography Discussion

  • •MLDSA/lattice vs. leanSPHINCS debate: EF crypto team holds hash-based is most conservative; MLDSA verifier costs ~800k–1.5M gas with current optimizations01:09:23
  • •Mislav (Ethlabs): wallet/UX concern — leanSPHINCS non-standard may repeat secp256k1 adoption problems; frames should remain scheme-agnostic01:13:44

Glamsterdam Spec Change Debate

  • •No spec change has majority support; any change restarts full audit/devnet/testnet cycle (~months delay)00:17:50
  • •Marius: removing mid-tx refunds (most-cited candidate change) breaks contracts relying on intra-tx gas return; significant unknown blast radius00:32:19
  • •Client poll: Geth, Nethermind, Reth, ethrex favor current spec + schedule; Erigon prefers spec change; Besu reluctantly accepts current spec00:40:09

Action items

  • •EL devs favoring spec change: produce concrete candidate change with impact analysis before next ACDCSpec change proponents (Erigon, Besu)
  • •All client teams: submit one-paragraph Hegota scope position (option 2–5) by end of next weekAll EL client teams
  • •Spencer: publish partial impact analysis doc for proposed Glamsterdam spec changesSpencer (testing)

Agenda

From the call issue #2285Show
  • Glamsterdam
    • status update by @rahul-kothari, see comment
    • Besu team position, see comment by @jflo
    • open discussion
    • potential Hoodi fork dates
  • Hegotá
    • Revisiting fork scope after devcon discussions
      • summary by @adietrichs
      • pointer: FOCIL decisions will be made on ACDC, EL core devs are asked to participate
      • open discussion
      • next steps
    • Frame transactions updates
    • Devnets next steps

Key decisions

  • Glamsterdam will proceed with current spec (no changes); Hoodi fork targeting week of Dec 14 — formal go/no-go at next ACDC

    SFIThe Glamsterdam spec is frozen to avoid audit and development delays; the Hoodi fork is tentatively scheduled for mid-December 2026.
  • Top Hegota scope option (drop frames, enshrine PQ directly) has zero support — effectively DFI'd; remaining options 2–4 open for two-week client team review

    DFIOption 1 for the Hegota scope, which involved dropping frames to enshrine post-quantum cryptography directly, was rejected due to lack of support.
  • No cross-layer Hegota DevNet until FOCIL decision is made on ACDC; EL DevNets remain separate

    Hegota DevNetCross-layer devnet activity for Hegota is paused pending a decision on FOCIL at the consensus layer meeting.
  • EL DevNet scope paused at current level by default; ACDT Monday may greenlight cleanup EIPs only

    EL DevNetThe scope for the Execution Layer DevNet is frozen at its current state, with potential exceptions only for minor cleanup EIPs.

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.