FOCIL2026-10-27_045

FOCIL Breakout #045

2026-10-27 2 decisions 328 transcript lines

Transcript

At a glance

Tentative preference for PR #5741 (only-timely IL bid selection) over #5740; final decision deferred pending bitlist-in-fork-choice discussion
Next FOCIL breakout rescheduled to November 10, 2026
FOCIL devnet-0 (with FOCIL-frame interaction) — after DEF CON; timeline TBD

Detailed notes

Spec Updates

  • •PR #5741 preferred over #5740: proposer considers only timely ILs when selecting bids, aligning with attester view and closing late-IL griefing attack00:08:06
  • •Second attack vector: builder broadcasts high early bid before IL deadline to crowd out compliant bids; fix is P2P gossip rule ignoring bids before IL deadline00:09:16
  • •PR #5769: Lodestar picks IL-unsatisfied payload as head; spec bug allows non-compliant payload to become head in current and next slot; fix under discussion00:25:22
  • •New FOCIL-frame engine API approach (Jihoon PRs #5772, execution-apis #960): CL passes raw ILs to EL instead of deduped IL transactions; EL handles deduplication and omission claims; max bandwidth overhead ~4.4% at 20M gas limit00:31:06

Client Updates

  • •Nethermind: quick slots and FOCIL devnet-3 changes implemented00:04:59
  • •Besu: quick slot feature not yet implemented; compliant only if slot time stays at 12s00:05:18
  • •Lodestar: FOCIL devnet-3 changes in trunk branch, merging into unstable00:06:11
  • •Prysm: FOCIL work landing in trunk, involved in devnet-2 and devnet-300:07:13

Organizational

  • •Next FOCIL breakout pushed two weeks to November 10 due to DEF CON travel00:41:16

Testing Progress

  • •FOCIL-frame interaction design must be settled before targeting FOCIL devnet-0; timeline not yet set, likely after DEF CON00:39:00

Action items

  • •Review PR #5769 (IL-unsatisfied payload as head bug) and suggest fixesCL client teams
  • •Review and provide feedback on FOCIL-frame engine API PRs (consensus-specs #5772, execution-apis #960) ahead of L1 days discussionEL and CL client teams

Agenda

From the call issue #2286Show
  • Development updates
  • Spec updates
  • Testing updates
  • and more

Key decisions

  • Tentative preference for PR #5741 (only-timely IL bid selection) over #5740; final decision deferred pending bitlist-in-fork-choice discussion

    Proposer considers only timely ILs when selecting bids to align with attester view and close late-IL griefing attack.
  • Next FOCIL breakout rescheduled to November 10, 2026

    Rescheduled due to DEF CON travel.

AI Disclaimer: Some content or metadata on EIPsInsight may be AI-inferred or automatically compiled. If you find any discrepancy, please contact us at dev@avarch.org.