AllCoreDevs — Consensus #175
Transcript
Ask about this call
Answered from this call's summary and transcript only.
AI-generated — verify against the recording.
Call summary
Targets
- •End of February - EPBS DevNet-0 launch with 2-3 clients — 00:10:30
Decisions
- •FOCIL (EIP-7805) selected as Hegotá headliner — 00:16:24
- •2D PeerDAS partial reconstruction proposal DFI'd for Hegotá — 00:17:04
Highlights
- Specifications:
- ·Variable PTC deadline PR still open; discussion ongoing — 00:12:02
- ·FOCIL rebased onto Gloas in consensus-specs PR 4931 — 00:16:39
- Epbs Devnet Progress:
- ·Kurtosis config with Lighthouse working locally — 00:08:02
- ·Lighthouse single-client demo ready in 1-2 weeks — 00:09:45
- ·Teku ready for initial devnet attempt next week — 00:09:57
- ·Prysm progressing; few PRs remaining before devnet-ready — 00:10:00
- ·DevNet-0 target: end of February with 2-3 clients — 00:09:40
- Fork Status And Schedule:
- ·FOCIL selected as Hegotá headliner; 2D PeerDAS proposal DFI'd — 00:14:04
Action Items
- •Justin Traglia — Rename EIP-7805 to Heze after consensus-specs PR merge — 00:17:13
- •stokes — Create CFI PR for FOCIL as Hegotá headliner — 00:18:28
Meeting chat130
- Sanggu Han
sounds great
- stokes
- Parithosh Jayanthi
Kurtosis config with lighthouse working: https://discord.com/channels/595666850260713488/874767108809031740/1474012924380188703
- Toni Wahrstätter
Reacted to Kurtosis config with... with "🔥"
- Enrico Del Fante (tbenr)
Reacted to "Kurtosis config with..." with 🔥
- James He
Reacted to "Kurtosis config with..." with 🔥
- Sanggu Han
Reacted to "Kurtosis config with..." with 🔥
- Mario Vega
Reacted to "Kurtosis config with..." with 🔥
- Agnish Ghosh
Reacted to "Kurtosis config with..." with 🔥
- kingy_sigp
lighthouse obviously has a lighthouse only devnet going - bit hacky but ready in a week or two
- Stefan Bratanov
Teku should be ready for next week initial try for devnet
- James He
Still have a few more prs to merge to develop / open for review but moving forward on it
- Satyajit
Reacted to "Kurtosis config wi..." with 🔥
- kingy_sigp
Reacted to "Teku should be ready..." with 👏
- kingy_sigp
Reacted to "Still have a few mor..." with 👏
- Trent
Was there a decision made on variable PTC deadlines?
- Justin Traglia
Replying to "Was there a decision..." No, the PR has not been merged yet.
- Justin Traglia
Replying to "Was there a decision..." https://github.com/ethereum/consensus-specs/pull/4843
- Trent
Replying to "Was there a decision..." Not that it should be in the devnet. But curious whether people are leaning one way or another
- Francesco
I don’t think it’s super helpful to discuss here, but would help for more people to take a look and express opinions on how they think it *should* work
- Justin Traglia
Reacted to "I don’t think it’s s..." with 👍
- Jihoon
Reacted to "I don’t think it’s s..." with 👍
- Toni Wahrstätter
Replying to "Was there a decision..." It's not super trivial because big blocks can still cause a lot of (excution) work
- stokes
- Justin Florentine (Besu)
did CL teams publish position papers?
- kingy_sigp
we've previously stated our case - pro focil
- Enrico Del Fante (tbenr)
We confirm our FOCIL support!
- nflaig
Lodestar team is pro focil
- Agnish Ghosh
as per discussions with the nimbus team - we'd like to prioritise FOCIL over 2d peerdas
- Ansgar Dietrichs
FOCIL headliner selection party, everyone get in
- kingy_sigp
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 😂
- g1
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner se..." with 🎉
- Parithosh Jayanthi
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 😂
- nixo
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 😂
- soispoke
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 😂
- Leo (MigaLabs)
Reacted to FOCIL headliner sele... with "😂"
- nixo
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- Katya
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🥳
- felix (eest)
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner se..." with 🎉
- Jihoon
FYI, this is a PR that rebases FOCIL onto Gloas: https://github.com/ethereum/consensus-specs/pull/4931
- Justin Florentine (Besu)
ascii art needs to be dinosaurs
- kingy_sigp
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- Enrico Del Fante (tbenr)
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- Ladislaus
Hat auf "FOCIL headliner sele..." mit 🎉 reagiert
- felix (eest)
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner se..." with 🥳
- Daniel Knopik
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner se..." with 🎉
- Daniel Knopik
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner se..." with 🥳
- kingy_sigp
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🥳
- soispoke
Replying to "ascii art needs to b..." yes
- Justin Traglia
Reacted to "FYI, this is a PR th..." with 🔥
- Mehdi Aouadi
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 😂
- nflaig
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 😂
- soispoke
Reacted to "FYI, this is a PR th..." with 🔥
- Ansgar Dietrichs
Replying to "FOCIL headliner sele..." most blatant emoji farming yet
- Ahmad Wilson
Reacted to Kurtosis config with... with "🔥"
- Satyajit
Reacted to "ascii art needs to..." with 😂
- Mehdi Aouadi
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🥳
- Leo (MigaLabs)
Reacted to FOCIL headliner sele... with "🎉"
- Mehdi Aouadi
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- nflaig
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- kingy_sigp
Replying to "ascii art needs to b..." it's so perfect it writes itself
- Will Corcoran
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- nixo
Reacted to "most blatant emoji f..." with 😂
- Ben Edgington
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🥳
- Leo (MigaLabs)
Reacted to ascii art needs to b... with "😂"
- Iván | Lambda
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- nixo
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🥳
- Jihoon
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- Daniel Knopik
Reacted to "ascii art needs to..." with 🔥
- kingy_sigp
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- felix (eest)
Reacted to "FYI, this is a PR ..." with 🔥
- Mehdi Aouadi
Reacted to "FYI, this is a PR th..." with 🔥
- Justin Traglia
Sweet. And we’ll rename eip7805 -> heze after this gets merged.
- Matthew Keil
Reacted to "FOCIL headliner sele..." with 🎉
- Jihoon
Reacted to "Sweet. And we’ll ren..." with 🔥
- Mehdi Aouadi
Reacted to "Sweet. And we’ll ren..." with 🔥
- Jihoon
Replying to "FYI, this is a PR th..." Sounds like a plan
- Mario Vega
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 😂
- soispoke
Reacted to "Sweet. And we’ll ren..." with 🔥
- Justin Florentine (Besu)
Replying to "ascii art needs to b..." i feel like a besusaurus is basically a brontosaurus?
- Mehdi Aouadi
Replying to "FYI, this is a PR th..." Finally 🥲
- Ahmad Wilson
Reacted to FOCIL headliner sele... with "😂"
- Justin Florentine (Besu)
Replying to "ascii art needs to b..." this is a loosely held opinion
- Ahmad Wilson
Reacted to ascii art needs to b... with "🔥"
- Ahmad Wilson
Reacted to FYI, this is a PR th... with "🔥"
- Jihoon
Reacted to "Finally 🥲" with 🤝
- Justin Traglia
Reacted to "Finally 🥲" with 😁
- Parithosh Jayanthi
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 😂
- Parithosh Jayanthi
Reacted to "most blatant emoji f..." with 😂
- nflaig
Reacted to "FYI, this is a PR th..." with 🔥
- Ansgar Dietrichs
maybe someone can reach out to John Adler to ask if he wants to relaunch his original L2 as FOCIL Fuel
- nixo
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- Sanggu Han
Reacted to "FYI, this is a PR th..." with 🔥
- Kalo | Obol
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- Justin Florentine (Besu)
DINOSAURS
- nixo
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🦕
- Enrico Del Fante (tbenr)
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🙃
- nixo
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🦖
- soispoke
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🦖
- James He
For prysm too we discussed internally we don’t have an official statement but we also leaned towards FOCIL
- soispoke
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🦕
- soispoke
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 😂
- soispoke
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- Ansgar Dietrichs
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with ❤️
- nixo
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦖
- Lumi | Offchain Labs
Reacted to "For prysm too we dis..." with 💙
- nixo
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦕
- Satyajit
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦕
- Ansgar Dietrichs
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦖
- Ansgar Dietrichs
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦕
- nixo
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🙃
- nixo
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with ❤️
- Kalo | Obol
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦕
- Katya
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🦕
- Kalo | Obol
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🦖
- Parithosh Jayanthi
Reacted to "DINOSAURS" with 🙃
- Katya
Reacted to "For prysm too we dis..." with 💙
- nixo
max efficiency
- nflaig
Reacted to "ascii art needs to b..." with 🔥
- soispoke
Reacted to "max efficiency" with 👍
- Justin Traglia
Reacted to "max efficiency" with 🔥
- Sanggu Han
Reacted to "max efficiency" with 🎉
- dionysuz.eth
Reacted to "max efficiency" with 🔥
- Justin Traglia
Bye everyone!
- Katya
Reacted to "max efficiency" with 🔥
- Trent
Reacted to "max efficiency" with 👍
- Ladislaus
Hat auf "max efficiency" mit 👍 reagiert
- Marius van der Wijden
Non headliner proposals?
- Parithosh Jayanthi
Reacted to "Non headliner propos..." with 🫥
- Ansgar Dietrichs
Replying to "Non headliner propos..." where we are going we don’t need non headliner proposals
Key decisions
FOCIL (EIP-7805) selected as Hegotá headliner
headlinerFOCIL was selected as the headliner for Hegotá2D PeerDAS partial reconstruction proposal DFI'd for Hegotá
The 2D PeerDAS partial reconstruction proposal was deferred for Hegotá